May 1, 2011

What To Tell Your Children

I'm not a psychologist, I'm not a teacher and I am surely not a political pundit. Take this post at face value.

I'm a Mama. A Mama who knew immediately last night that I had some explaining to do to my children about the killing of Osama Bin Laden. My mind raced trying to come up with the words I would use to explain to Ryan, 10 and Jack, 8.

On September 11, 2001 Ryan was not quite 6 months old and Jack was still a dream. But that evening, I wrote my children a letter. I explained to them what happen, using words that I imagined children could understand. There are tears on that letter, and, like on this blog, I didn't edit my feelings.

In 2003, my mother bought 2 children's books for the the minis which we have read repeatedly and discussed ad nauseum. I have included the links below if you're interested.

The first one is, The Little Chapel That Stood. It is the story of St. Paul Chapel which is situated between the Twin Towers. It not only survived 9/11, but served as a comfort and base for those serving in the days that followed.

The second book is, September 12: We Knew Everything Would Be Alright. It is written mostly by 1st graders, with art work that addresses the simple comforts and daily routines following 9/11. It is a hopeful book that tells children that even after bad things happen, things will be ok.

I pulled those books out, re-read them and made some notes. I sat the minis down this morning and used the words that I thought would be helpful to them.

I said,

"I know you remember what happened on September 11 with the airplanes and the Towers. Ten years ago many, many people on our country were killed. Some of them were normal people just going to work. A lot of them were firefighters, EMT, and police officers. There was a man who was the boss of the terrible group of people called Al Quaeda. They are terrorists. They hate America. They hate us.

When that happened, President Bush told the American people that we would find that man, named Osama Bin Laden. For 10 years, our soldiers have been looking for him. He has been hiding. Last week, they told the new President, who is the head of the military, that they were pretty sure they knew where he was. President Obama gave them permission to go there, and to kill him. Yesterday they found him. They shot him with a gun and he is dead.

I need you to listen very carefully boys. Are you listening to me? Look at my eyes and listen.

That will never happen to you. That happened to a very horrible man who did horrible things. Your Daddy and I will keep you safe, and so will the soldiers that protect you. Do you understand? That happened very far away from us. You would have to take a plane to get there. Not here. Not close to our house or your school.

I know it's confusing and you have lots of questions. I will answer all of those questions. When you get to school today, people are going to be talking about this. Many of your friends may say some really stupid things about this. I need you to understand that talking like that is not ok.

If you hear people saying inappropriate things, this is what I want you to say.

"I am glad our soldiers are keeping me safe." Just like we say whenever we see a soldier. We shake their hands and say "Thank you for keeping me safe." None of those soldiers were hurt yesterday.

When you get home, you can tell me all of the things that your friends were saying at school. It's absolutely ok to repeat all of those things to me and to Daddy. It is not ok to repeat them to anyone else.

This is a big deal. My stomach hurts, and maybe yours does too. Tell me what questions you have. I don't know everything but I will help you figure it out."

Jack had some questions about guns and the Ten Commandments. I used this opportunity to talk to them about the Catholic Church's stance on respect for human life and legitimate defense. In little people words of course.

When I pick the minis up from school, I am prepared for more discussion and questions. I am prepared to help them navigate the comments and thoughts of their friends. I expect that Sister Mary Jacinta may have prayed with them.

These might not be the right words for your children. Maybe they are older, or younger or more scared. I don't know if these are the words I should have used. I do know that we need to talk to them. To ensure them they we are doing everything we can to keep them safe.


God Bless America. God Bless Our Children.

31 comments:

cami said...

I think God gave you a lot of wisdom in handling this situation w/ the minis. I think I will use a similar tactic in my classroom today.

Heather said...

Thank you for these great suggestions!

Anonymous said...

Great entry ... I am mulling over how to talk about it with my kids, and I will definitely keep this in mind. You are a thoughtful mama!

LeonsGirl1921 said...

Jenn, you're probably gonna hate me for this one....

I live in Northern NJ, about 15 miles outside New York City. When I drive to work I can see the Empire State Building. My daughter was in her 5th day of kindergarten when the towers fell, and my son was 18 months old. Two days - TWO DAYS - before 9/11 we took our kids to the Bronx Zoo and as we drove over the George Washington Bridge, I pointed out the Towers to my kids and told them that some day we would take a trip to the top and look out the beautiful windows.

The day it happened, we drove as close as we could to NYC and we all watched the burning and the smoke from the Jersey side. The fighter jets were flying overhead so loudly they hurt our ears. Our skies were then silent for days and it scared us when the planes finally started to fly again. My kids have known about this their whole lives and are used to it, if you ever get used to such a thing.

Last night my daughter (now 15)stayed up to watch the news reports with me and said "Thank God he's finally dead." This morning my son (now 11) came home from his dad's house and said "We finally killed the son of a bitch." And I did not reprimand or correct him.

That's life in Jersey in what used to be the shadow of the Towers. God bless us all.

Jaime Nash said...

You are amazing! This is perfect. Our little girl is almost 8 months old, so right now we don't have any explaining to her to do. But, I know, oh I know, that there are still some difficult situations ahead that will need to be explained and I pray that I can say it as well as you have. Thank you for sharing.

Mommy's Muffin said...

Your response to your children's questions concerning the killing of Osama are so timely. This morning my 2nd grade daughter (She also attends Catholic school.) was confused about the killing and commented it was against God's commandments to kill. Thanks for helping me handle her questions & confusion in a thoughtful and age appropriate manner.

Anonymous said...

A lot of overkill (no pun intended) don't you think??!?!?!? I definitely think you put way more focus on this than was needed. They are way to young to understand the ramifications. You probably put more fear in them than you were trying to relieve. Yes, they need to know there are bad people out there....but to tell them, at their age, that the President gave the ok for the military to "kill" OBL - I'm disgusted. All they needed to be told was that the US military found OBL, and he was killed when he and some other bad men shot at our troops. They do not have the cognitive ability (regardless of how gifted) at 10 & 8 to understand the justification. This requires higher order thinking skills - that NO HUMAN develops at such a young age - ask any reputable psychiatrist/psychologist.

Anonymous said...

I think you are a great mother. Just sayin'

laura said...

I love how you explained it to your kids. You are an amazing mom, and your family is so lucky to have you!

EH said...

Hi Clemsongirl, I'm a fan of your blog and your tweets - @eriniscrafty - and I just wanted to let you know that when I read your blogs like this, they are truly a lesson in parenting for me. I appreciate you being so honest and open with how you choose to handle these situations with your children. It makes me think hard about how I'll handle things like this with my future children. What I would say, how I will teach them values, what will be important for our family.
Thanks for keeping such an honest and open blog!
Erin

Lisa said...

Great post. You have made me think about how to parent my three year old. Thank you for being open and honest! :)

Karen said...

@Anonymous....WOW. Harsh.

Clemsongirl - praying for strength for you in continuing your dialog with your boys. Peace be with you tonight.

Anonymous said...

They are blessed to have you as their mama.

Rebecca K.

clemsongirlandthecoach said...

Anonymous, I can't email you, b/c you're well...anonymous. It's so easy to leave comments that way. I have no idea how old your children are, if you have any, what their level of understanding is and what they need to hear.

I'm super glad that you know about Bloom’s Taxonomy and higher order thinking. I, however, know that I told my children exactly what they needed to hear.

Telling my children about "bad men" wouldn't have been helpful. Whether or not they are gifted, and one is, has no bearing on "cognitive ability" in this instance. Further, I think telling them that the President gave the military "permission" is extremely important. Children need to know that someone is in charge. At least my children do.

I never claimed to have all the right answers. I claim to be a mother who cares deeply about my children and monitoring what they hear and helping them interpret it.

To say that you are "disgusted" with me seems both pedestrian and not neccesary.

Lastly, I spent an hour with the Archdioses School Psychologist today. She agreed that I did exactly the right thing. I used the right words.

She didn't mention however, that She thought you were incredibly rude.

But I will.

Anonymous said...

Why are you promising something that you have no control over? It is entirely possible (highly unlikely, but entirely possible) that terrorists (foreign or domestic) could again attack the U.S.
There were children affected on 9/11, in the Oklahoma City bombing, and the Atlanta Olympic bombing, to name a few.
And, God forbid, someone is hurt in an accident or becomes ill. You have no power to prevent any of this, and shouldn't pretend to.
I think it's fine to say you will do your best to protect your children, but you shouldn't pretend to them that you are all-powerful. You are not.

clemsongirlandthecoach said...

If Navy Seals bust into my house and shoot my children? I'm pretty sure that isn't going to happen. Get a grip.

Duh.

Amanda said...

Dear Anonymous -
Get off your high horse and stop hatin' on ClemsonGirl. She's more of a mom than you could think about being. And while you're at it, stop hiding behind your computer screen. The blog world is here to support one another, not point out other's faults. You've gone too far.

peace, love, and ClemsonGirl.

K said...

Clemsongirl, I copied your post and sent it to my children's teachers and other mommy friends. I think at the ages our children are, the best thing they can feel, in any circumstance, is safe. With your words, you thoughtfully and carefully did that. That is what we wanted as kids - that is what they want now. And one day, they will likely use the same words in a crisis situation when trying to make their OWN children know that mom and dad will keep them safe.

Anyone who blasts you anonymously should just stay anonymous.

Rebecca said...

Clemsongirl- 2
Anonymous-0

Go Tigers, rawr.

Kristi said...

Thanks for this, CG. You moved me to tears, literally.

Hope you son't mind - but I shared your words over on my corner of the internet today.

God bless you - and your minis.

http://theveedubs.blogspot.com/

BroncoMom said...

Wow CG, you nailed it perfectly!!

Allison Curti said...

I am a firm believer in talking about things and making sure our children know we are going to protect them with all we have. I think you did a fantastic job. They see things and hear things, esp at that age and it can be so scary to them. Great job!

Shell said...

Dear Anonymous,

You are an IDIOT.

The End.

Anne said...

Jenn, this post truly brought me to tears earlier today. What a perfect way to comfort your boys and clarify the situation.

Whatever Anonymous (or any other variety of internet "experts") may know, she doesn't know YOUR minis. You do - and clearly they benefits from that immensely.

So glad you shared this with us. I'm thankful today to have a little one too small to be aware of this. One day, though, I'll look to you for these kind of things. Write me some scripts?

xo

~Kristen said...

Coming out of "lurkdom" to applaud you CG!! I don't even remember how I found your blog years ago, but have continued reading for love of your Southern charm, wit and pure honesty!

As a teacher of children that are too young to remember that day, what you prepared your boys with was perfect. I heard a lot of inappropriate comments and incorrect information coming out of the mouths of my kids today. I live and teach in an area that was highly effected by loss from the events of 9/11. I literally sat in school that day with kids whom we had no one to send them home to.

@annon... not only are you a coward who can't stand by your immature and unworldly words... you also have no idea how aware and often misinformed kids are because of parents who try to convince them we live in a world of sunshine and rainbows. Grow up... and educate your kids, no matter what age they are... This post is a perfect example of age appropriate conversation.

And CG, you have every right to promise your kids you will protect them always... that is your job the second they come into this world. Fate may step in at any moment, but it will not counter the force you will use to prevent tragedy. That is the unspoken promise.

Love this post... and so many others! :o)

Dori said...

Definitely not a dull moment in blog land huh?! Well, I think bottom line it is up to you how you choose to tell your children and what you choose to tell them. We did not discuss it with the boys...just too young. I told Reagan about it this morning; but did not discuss in great detail. She is just too happy that her Dad is home safe and sound with us. I can't take the chance that she will put two and two together and come to understand just what his role in all this was over the last few years. Well, actually her whole life...
I, for the most part am sticking to the best quote I heard all day on Twitter:

"The girl married her prince, the bad guy is dead; it's certainly been a Disney weekend here on Earth!"

Anonymous said...

Holy cow, Jenn! According to anon. I guess I am saying the wrong thing, too. I tell my kids that I will never let anything happen to them, knowing darn well that I cannot control that at all. But I guess next time I should just tell them, "Well, someone might hit you with their car, or accidently shoot you but I hope not."
Sheesh....
On the other hand, I love what you told the boys. I had a similar talk with C. this morning, as well. (You did a much better job than I did) But I felt it was my job as his mother to let him know with "big" words so that he didn't get the wrong story at school.
Lesly

Anonymous said...

I forgot....love you!
Lesly

Miss CJAC said...

I am just a college senior at Clemson (go tigers!) who has followed your blog for quite some time. Your post today was awesome. I am no where near ready to be a parent, but I have to tell you that I look up to your parenting and even more so after this post. I think what you said to your children was great. I'm inspired and hope that when I do finally become a mother, that I am just as thoughtful, creative, and loving as you proved you are (once again) in your post today.
God Bless and Go Tigers! :)

Princess Freckles said...

You did an outstanding job explaining OBL's death to your sons!

In response to the anonymous comment, I distinctly remember my mother explaing the Holocaust to me. I was under the age of 8. I remember my age because we had the conversation sitting on the couch in the home lived in until I was 8 years old. I have no idea why it was brought up, but I know I asked about it. I had heard some things, and I had heard of Ann Frank. My mother explained, as best she could, who Ann Frank was, and what happened to her and 6 million others during WWII. To say a child of that age cannot understand or doesn't have the cognitive ability to understand is just false. Children understand injustice, hatred, danger, and punishment. They have a very clear understanding of these concepts and an almost simplistic understanding of crime and punishment.

I'll never forget having that conversation with my mother and my response. I remember crying a little for Ann Frank and the other people killed. My mother explained that our military and others fought Hitler and won. Very much like how you explained Obama "giving the order to kill OBL".

Bravo! Don't ever question how you tackle these horrible realities with your children. They understand, and it's always best that they are explained things by you and your husband in the way you see fit.

Anonymous said...

As someone who lived/worked in NYC on 9/11, a Mother and a member of the US Intelligence Community (which is why I am remaining anon here), I think you said all the right things to your children. It's a sticky situation and why scare them unnecessarily with threats of what might happen in the future. They are children and as parents we are there to protect them as best we can. They look to us for that protection and comfort.